Flying Geese


The Asian Tiger grew up

A comment on my new Ground Level: Vietnam newsletter taught me something new this week. After nearly 40 years working in Asia, I didn't expect that.

​Kim Peters, an international school leader, wrote that what I'd described reminded her of 'The Flying Geese model'. This was new to me so I had to look it up.

The idea is that Asian economies develop in a V formation. Japan led and the others followed. As each one got richer, it handed its factories to the goose behind and moved on to harder work.

Kim has lived it. Born in Korea, Japan in 1994, China in 1996, Vietnam, and most recently India.

The Japanese economist Kaname Akamatsu described it in the 1930s, half a century before I arrived in Hong Kong.

In 1987 we had our own animal. Investing in the 'Asian Tigers'. Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan. Everyone understood it. It was a dinner party conversation, and it formed a large part of every client portfolio in those days.

Nobody says it now. The Asian crisis took the shine off, and the word slipped quietly out of fashion.

Akamatsu's geese explain where they went. The tigers didn't disappear. They're rich economies now, near the front of the formation. Behind them it runs through China and on into Southeast Asia, too long and too varied for any one animal.

In 1987, the word 'tiger' was enough to sell Asia. Today no word is big enough.

PS. Last week I launched a second, shorter newsletter just on Vietnam. Ground Level: Vietnam is one story from the street every two weeks, and why it matters. The second issue will be out soon. It’s a separate list, so you’ll only get it if you sign up here.​

Think Global with David Thomas

I empower business leaders, entrepreneurs and investors to successfully invest, raise capital and/or do business in the Asia Pacific region. Subscribe to my newsletter to receive my regular updates, insights and commentary on what's happening in Asia and why it matters

Read more from Think Global with David Thomas

Vietnam today looks a lot like the China I got to know. Over the past twelve months I've been to Hanoi, Da Nang and Ho Chi Minh City. Each visit was an eye-opener. Cranes everywhere. Holes in the ground. Building sites on every other block. And people everywhere, working hard and on the move. I've seen it before. I visited China regularly from 1989 to 2019 and watched it build itself the same way. The parallels are hard to miss. The numbers say the same thing. Vietnam's economy grew 9.95% in...

Why fly the student when you can fly the course?

What would a real win-win look like? Last week a delegation from Australia came to Cebu, which doesn't happen often. I was glad to be invited. Half the room was Australian, half local, and the mood was warm and friendly. They'd come to do business. The business turned out to be recruitment. Young Filipinos trained in Australia for the jobs Australia can't fill. Aged care, nursing, plumbing, electrical work. Nothing wrong with that. Australia needs the workers. Plenty of Filipinos want the...

Marriott turns 100 next year. Asia should be taking notes. In Washington this month I stayed at the Marriott Hotel in Bethesda. It sits right next to the company's global headquarters, a tower of more than 20 storeys. I found myself wondering how a company ends up with a building like that. So I started reading. It started in 1927 as a root beer stand on 14th Street. Nine seats. J. Willard and Alice Marriott, newlyweds from Utah. When winter came and nobody wanted a cold drink, they added hot...